Den Rating!

[Wurt the Merm]

So i'll be rating your camps, and will be deciding if the area and build is low-tier or excellent!
How i'll rate it:

Aesthetic, basically the area you chose and how you've decorated and built it.
Tile, the tile is required to make a camp. Without any tiles, there is no camp.
Brambles, just if there are brambles near the area.
Water, if there's water in the area.
Prey, from New-leaf to Leaf-bare i'll rate how much prey there is in the seasons.
Overall rating, overall rating. All of them combined from 0-50.

Here i'll rate the tile. And not your dens.

Shadowclan, one area above a no-car road.





Aesthetics - Very nice looking! A few trees that could get in the way, which could be a problem. But let's be real, it's a very pretty tile! 6/10.
Tile - It's in aesthetics.
Brambles - There's a bramble above, left, right and bellow! 10/10.
Water - Water on the tile, water above, and trees for moss. 8/10.
Prey - As someone who has had many camps in Shadowclan, i can say the prey kinda dwindles unless you have a den in the Carrionplace.

Overall Rating? - I'd say a 36/50. Mostly because of prey and the trees that block the way.



Aesthetics - Actuallllllllllllllllly pretty! The stump could be used as an easy prey-pile and i just think it's kind of pretty. 5/10
Tile - This.. I actually don't like the tile. There's little space and can easily be filled to the brim with thickets and cats if your not careful. I give the overall tile 3/10.
Brambles - A few spawn nearby. So 9/10.
Water - A tile next to it has water, and there's lots of trees to get moss from.
Prey - It's Riverclan, i suggest hunting in Windclan if your not doing a challenge where you have to stay in a zone.
Overall Rating - Very little space, sorta boring when it comes to aesthetics. 23/50.

[Wurt the Merm]

Update! I've now added something else to the basic tile list, the most popular.. BLANK TILE!

Aesthetics: It's very boring, but there are a few decorative bushes and the weird half moss and bramble. 2/10 for aesthetics.
Tile: It's pretty boring. But it's gud. 8/10
Brambles: A bramble spawns on this tile, a bramble spawns near, and 2 tiles away there are 2 bramble havens! 9/10.
Water: Water isn't very close. But there are trees that can provide moss, which produces both bedding and water! 6/10
Prey: It's Windclan. Lots of prey depending on the tile! 7/10
Overall Rating: Actually a 47/50! It's because of the tile being sorta boring that i brought it down by a few points.

So, what are your rogue clans? Send a screenshot and i'll rate it!

[Something]

What about this?
Prey spawns in-camp as shown in the image

[Wurt the Merm]

Aesthetics: If anyone knows me, i've always sorta never liked spaced thickets. Tho it's perfectly understandable if you need time to hunt, Thunderclan cats could easily slip in since this is a battle tile. I really like where you placed the herbs tho! Also tip, put thickets next to the moss that isn't close enough to a thicket that you want cats to spawn on. It'll increase your chance of rogues spawning. 4/10 for this one.
Tile: I actually really like this tile! My only problem with it is the Thunderclan cats that come to fight, and the lack of space as it's a corner tile. 6/10
Brambles: A bramble spawns in 3 tiles above it! And a bramble to the tile next to it. Heck, one of those tiles spawn 2 brambles! 8/10.
Water: Water is on the tile, there are trees to get moss on, and 2 tiles next to it has water. And lots of trees on every tile! 10/10.
Prey: Prey spawns in camp, prey is nearby, one tile is filled with mice. 9/10
Overall Rating: I give it a 32/50. It isn't bad, and most of it was my personal opinion. Do whatever! But i do still give the advice of putting thickets near moss you want cats to spawn on.